Scoring System

Monday, April 27, 2026

Scoring System

 Rating criteria

1-10 licks 

  • Flavor Selection
    • 0: No maple. 
    • 1: Yes maple. 
  • Value (accounts for both price and pour size of a SIZE SMALL in cheapest cone offered)
    • 0: poor-fine value
    • 1: good-great value
  • Texture
    • 0: Very icy or otherwise weird
    • 1: Slightly icy or otherwise weird
    • 2: Totally smooth and correct
    • 3: unusually decadent 
  • Flavor
    • 0: Unusually terrible or weak
    • 1: Standard cheap maple flavor
    • 2: Better than normal real maple flavor
    • 3: exceptional strong real maple flavor 
  • Window
    • 0: Indoor service window/counter
    • 1: Outdoor service window/counter 
  • Bonus
    • Up to 1 point for exceptional ambiance or other unique features.
  • TOTAL
    • 0-10 LICKS